CA Final · Advanced Auditing, Assurance and Professional Ethics · Audit Planning, Strategy and Execution
CA Sunita is planning the audit of Konkan Energy Ltd, which values complex unlisted derivative holdings through internal models. While planning, she sees that the team lacks the skills to evaluate the valuation models. The engagement partner must be satisfied about the team's capabilities. Which conclusion is most consistent with SA 540 and SA 300 planning requirements?
She should ascertain the resources needed, including involvement of people with specialised skills or knowledge where necessary, and ensure the team and any experts collectively have the capabilities, competence and time. Skills needs may also emerge during the audit, and responsibility cannot be passed to management's team.
- AIgnore the matter, since specialised skills are only a concern during the reporting phase
- BAscertain the nature, timing and extent of resources needed, which may include involving those with specialised skills or knowledge, and ensure the team collectively has appropriate capabilities, competence and timeCorrect
- CAsk management's valuation team to perform the evaluation, thereby transferring responsibility for the opinion
- DReduce the scope of the audit on the derivatives since the model is proprietary
Explanation
SA 540 says that in planning the auditor ascertains the nature, timing and extent of resources, which may include specialised skills or knowledge, and SA 220 requires the engagement partner to be satisfied that the team and any experts collectively have appropriate capabilities, competence and time. Using management's team does not give independent evidence, and scope cannot be reduced simply because a model is proprietary.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Audit Planning, Strategy and Execution shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Audit Planning, Strategy and Execution questions
- In the audit of Bharat Steels Ltd, the internal audit function has tested the entity's valuation of a complex long-term provision whose meas…
- During the audit of Himalaya Pharma Ltd, materiality is Rs 50 lakh. The auditor has accumulated uncorrected misstatements of Rs 46 lakh so f…
- During the audit of Bharat Pumps Ltd, CA Rohan has accumulated uncorrected misstatements of Rs 18 lakh against an overall materiality of Rs …
- Deccan Pharma Ltd has an internal audit function that has tested its inventory counts and also evaluated management's going concern assumpti…
- During the audit of Himalaya Foods Ltd, CA Rohit accumulates misstatements. Individually they are small, but the aggregate of misstatements …
- During the audit of Himalaya Foods Ltd, CA Meera accumulates misstatements. Materiality is Rs 50 lakh and the aggregate of uncorrected misst…