ACCA Applied Skills · Corporate and Business Law (Global) · International trade, international legal regulation and conflict of laws
Delta Co and Echo Co agree that their contract is governed by the law of Country M. Country M law permits a term that the courts of the forum, Country N, regard as contrary to a fundamental mandatory rule protecting its public interest. Delta Co sues in Country N to enforce the term. What is the most likely outcome?
The Country N court may refuse to apply the term on public policy grounds. Choice of governing law is respected but limited by the forum's mandatory rules and public policy, and it does not oust the court's jurisdiction or void the contract everywhere.
- AThe Country N court must enforce the term because the chosen governing law always overrides the forum's rules
- BThe Country N court must transfer the case to Country M, since a governing law clause removes jurisdiction
- CThe Country N court may refuse to apply the term on public policy grounds, even though Country M law governs the contractCorrect
- DThe whole contract becomes void in every country because of the conflict
Explanation
Party autonomy is limited by the forum's public policy and overriding mandatory rules. A governing law clause selects the law but does not remove the forum's jurisdiction, and refusal to enforce one term does not void the contract worldwide.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on International trade, international legal regulation and conflict of laws shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More International trade, international legal regulation and conflict of laws questions
- Which of the following best describes the main purpose of the World Trade Organization (WTO)?
- A dispute between a trader in Country P and a supplier in Country Q is heard by a court in Country P. The court notes that P's legal system …
- Kestria, a civil law country, has a comprehensive written commercial code. A dispute arises over a supply contract, and the party relying on…
- Country P imports goods already subject to its tariff. After the goods clear customs and are sold domestically, Country P imposes an extra i…
- Delmar Inc and Esker GmbH agree that 'the courts of Country P shall have exclusive jurisdiction over any dispute'. The contract is silent on…
- Kestrel Ltd and Dunmore Ltd agree in their contract that 'the courts of Country X shall have exclusive jurisdiction.' Kestrel later sues Dun…