ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Leader · Enabling success: organising
Dunmore Pharma operates in a stable, mass-production environment making a limited range of generic drugs. A consultant proposes replacing its functional structure with a matrix organised around product teams and geographic managers. Applying contingency thinking, which assessment is most appropriate?
The matrix is probably unsuitable. Contingency thinking says structure should fit the environment and strategy, and a stable, narrow, mass-production setting is best served by a functional structure that gains efficiency from specialisation, whereas a matrix adds cost and complexity suited to dynamic, complex settings.
- AThe matrix is likely unsuitable, as a stable, low-complexity environment fits a functional structure with efficiency from specialisationCorrect
- BThe matrix is ideal, as matrix structures always improve performance in any environment
- CThe matrix is suitable only if the firm abandons all specialist departments
- DThe matrix is needed because stable environments require maximum flexibility
Explanation
Contingency theory links structure to environment and strategy. Stable conditions and a narrow product range favour functional, mechanistic structures that deliver efficiency. A matrix adds cost and complexity suited to dynamic, multi-product or multi-market settings, so it is not justified here.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Enabling success: organising shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Enabling success: organising questions
- Tessera Print has a stable market, falling sales growth and strong cash flow. Its structure is highly formalised and innovation has slowed. …
- Brevik Retail is considering flattening its structure by removing two management layers, which will roughly double the average span of contr…
- Corvane Group has three autonomous divisions, each with its own finance, HR and IT teams. The board finds that the same systems are bought t…
- Teluk Foods has a tall hierarchy with narrow spans of control, and the board wants to reduce costs and speed up decisions by delayering. Whi…
- Aldersgate Insurance acquires Pennine Mutual, which has a collaborative, consensus-based culture, whereas Aldersgate is hierarchical with st…
- Marlowe Foods, a family-owned manufacturer, has one owner-director who approves every purchase order, hiring decision and price change. As t…