ACCA Strategic Professional · Advanced Performance Management · Sustainability
Karvale Ltd adopts the triple bottom line to report performance. The board proposes to present a single figure for 'people' performance that is expressed in the same monetary units as profit, so the three elements can be added together. Which is the most significant weakness of this proposal under the triple bottom line approach?
The main weakness is measurement. People and planet outcomes are hard to value in money, so adding them to profit needs subjective assumptions and reduces comparability. The framework still reports profit and applies to any organisation, and no cash basis rule exists.
- ASocial and environmental impacts are hard to measure in monetary terms, so a single additive figure involves subjective valuations and loses comparabilityCorrect
- BThe framework does not permit any reporting of profit
- CTriple bottom line only applies to public sector bodies
- DAdding the elements would breach the requirement to report on a cash basis
Explanation
The triple bottom line covers profit, people and planet. Its main criticism is that the social and environmental elements lack a common unit and are difficult to quantify, so converting them into money requires subjective judgements. The other options are false statements about the framework.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Sustainability shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Sustainability questions
- Orrin Textiles publishes an annual sustainability report. Investors complain that it lists many unrelated environmental statistics but does …
- Brightwell Ltd's board is deciding what to include in its integrated report. A proposed disclosure concerns a supplier dispute that could, o…
- Meridian Steel has an environmental management system that is certified to ISO 14001. Its directors say the company therefore has reliable s…
- Tamsin Retail has introduced a data dashboard that pulls electricity usage from smart meters in all 120 stores to report energy use per squa…
- Zenara Foods plc wants to report its environmental and social impacts alongside its financial results, so that each is measured against the …
- Zentra Plc, a manufacturer, wants to report on its performance in three dimensions: economic, environmental and social, so that shareholders…