ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Leader · Reporting to stakeholders
Tamsin Retail's board argues that voluntary social and environmental disclosure is pointless because investors only care about profit. The company secretary proposes continuing it. Which argument best supports the company secretary's view from a legitimacy and stakeholder perspective?
The best argument is that disclosure helps maintain the organisation's social licence to operate and manages relationships with stakeholders who influence long-term success. This reflects legitimacy and stakeholder perspectives. It is not universally mandatory, does not guarantee short-term profit and does not replace financial audit.
- ADisclosure helps maintain the organisation's social licence to operate and manages relationships with stakeholders who can affect its long-term successCorrect
- BDisclosure is legally required in every jurisdiction so there is no choice
- CDisclosure will automatically increase short-term profit
- DDisclosure replaces the need for any financial audit
Explanation
Legitimacy theory holds that organisations need society's approval, their social licence, to operate, and stakeholder theory says that stakeholders can affect long-term success. Disclosure supports both. The other options overstate: it is not universally mandatory, does not guarantee profit, and does not replace financial audit.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Reporting to stakeholders shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Reporting to stakeholders questions
- Halden Telecom has invested heavily in staff training, a proprietary software platform and brand reputation. The finance director says that,…
- Marlow Retail's board report states that the audit committee 'reviewed the effectiveness of internal controls' but gives no information on h…
- Tamsin Retail's board wants its social and environmental audit to give the most useful insight into whether the company is meeting stakehold…
- Valtora plc, a listed manufacturer, publishes an annual report containing audited financial statements, and a separate sustainability report…
- Zentara plc, a listed mining group, wants its annual report to show how its strategy, governance, performance and prospects lead to value cr…
- Kestrel Foods lists in a jurisdiction using a principles-based 'comply or explain' governance code. Its board chair is also the former chief…