ACCA Applied Skills · Corporate and Business Law (Global) · Other company officers
Tanvir Ltd's auditor is asked by the board to also design and implement the company's accounting system and prepare its financial statements. Which ground best explains why this threatens auditor independence?
The main concern is a self-review threat. If the auditor designs the accounting system and prepares the financial statements, it would then audit its own work, which undermines objectivity and independence. Fee levels, voting rights and duty of care are not the central issue.
- AThe auditor would be reviewing its own work, creating a self-review threatCorrect
- BThe auditor would be paid too little for the work
- CThe members would lose the right to vote on the auditor's appointment
- DThe auditor would no longer owe a duty of care to the company
Explanation
Designing the systems and preparing the statements means the auditor would later audit its own work, which is a self-review threat. Fees, voting rights and duty of care are not the issue raised by the scenario.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Other company officers shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Other company officers questions
- Paloma plc's auditor, Ravi, holds a small number of shares in Paloma plc, bought after his appointment. Under the usual company law rules on…
- Delmar Ltd's articles state that the company secretary has no authority to borrow money. The secretary, Mr Chen, nevertheless signed a loan …
- Harlow Co's auditor, Ms Vance, issued an unmodified opinion on financial statements which she negligently failed to discover were materially…
- Lindqvist Ltd's auditor, Aldous LLP, resigns during the year. Aldous believes there are circumstances connected with its resignation that sh…
- Marta is the finance director of Orion Plc, a company with an external audit. Her brother-in-law is a partner in Kell & Co, the firm propose…
- Brandt Ltd wishes to appoint Orla as its auditor. Orla is a qualified accountant but is also an employee of Brandt Ltd in its finance depart…