ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Leader · Strategic choices
Verano Hotels operates three luxury boutique hotels, each offering bespoke concierge services, unique local design and a premium room rate about 40% above the local average. Management now proposes to cut staff training and replace bespoke services with standard procedures to reduce costs while keeping the premium rate. Applying Porter's generic strategies, what is the main strategic risk of this proposal?
The main risk is becoming stuck in the middle. Cutting training and bespoke service weakens the uniqueness that supports the premium rate, while a small three-hotel operator cannot reach genuine cost leadership, so Verano could end up with neither a cost nor a differentiation advantage.
- AVerano will become stuck in the middle if it erodes the sources of differentiation that justify its premium without gaining a true cost leadership positionCorrect
- BVerano will move to a cost focus strategy, which is less profitable than differentiation
- CVerano will gain a cost advantage that automatically strengthens its differentiation
- DVerano will be forced to adopt a broad market scope, which is the same as cost leadership
Explanation
The premium rate depends on perceived uniqueness. Standardising services undermines it, yet three small hotels cannot achieve the scale for cost leadership. This leaves Verano with neither advantage, which Porter calls stuck in the middle. Cost savings do not automatically strengthen differentiation.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Strategic choices shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Strategic choices questions
- Kestrel Pharma operates in several countries. Regulators in each require locally approved formulations and pricing, but Kestrel's R&D is cos…
- Brightwater Airlines flies a single type of aircraft on point-to-point routes, uses secondary airports, sells only online and charges for al…
- Brightwell Group is a parent that holds many unrelated businesses. Its head office is small, gives units wide autonomy, and mainly sets fina…
- Halvorsen plc, a diversified group, has a business unit with low relative market share in a fast-growing market. It currently consumes more …
- Zentra Ltd sells industrial printers. It plans to stop selling the machines outright and instead charge customers a monthly fee based on pag…
- Kovalo Foods, a traditional grocer, launches a digital marketplace letting independent farmers sell directly to consumers, with Kovalo earni…