Skip to content

CMA Final · Cost and Management Audit

Cost Auditor: Section 148 Guide for CMA Final Paper 17

A cost auditor is a cost accountant appointed by the Board under Section 148 of the Companies Act, 2013 to audit the cost records of companies the Central Government has directed. To solve questions, check applicability first, then appointment, independence, rights and duties, reporting, and penalties for default.

What this chapter covers

This chapter covers the person who carries out a cost audit. You study how a cost auditor is appointed under Section 148, who can and cannot be appointed, when cost records and cost audit apply, what the auditor can demand from the company, what the auditor must report, and what happens on default.

The chapter sits at the base of Paper 17. Later chapters on cost auditing standards, the cost audit report and cost audit programme assume you know who the auditor is and what the legal limits are. Questions often mix these: a case gives a company's facts and asks whether the appointment, the report or the remuneration process is valid.

Most of the chapter rests on Section 148 and the Companies (Cost Records and Audit) Rules. Learn the section's sub-sections as a chain: order for cost records, order for audit, appointment, standards, report, filing with the Government, and penalty. If you see the chain, individual rules are easier to recall.

Section A of Paper 17 carries 15 compulsory MCQs, and this chapter gives clean, rule-based questions that you can get right with certainty, including case-scenario MCQs on appointment or independence. In the descriptive section, the same rules are tested through short case applications where you must state the rule, apply it to the facts and conclude. Few topics in the paper reward precise recall as directly, and the chapter also supports your answers in later chapters on the cost audit report.

Cost Auditor: topics in the order to study them

  1. 1Applicability of Cost Audit and Cost Records RulesStart here because every other rule applies only if a company is covered by cost records or cost audit.
  2. 2Cost Auditor Appointment under Section 148Once you know who is covered, learn how the Board appoints the auditor and how the Section 148 chain works.
  3. 3Qualification and Independence of Cost AuditorEligibility and bars to appointment are tested right after appointment, since they decide whether an appointment is valid.
  4. 4Rights, Duties and Powers of Cost AuditorWith the appointment settled, learn what the auditor can access and must do, including reporting to the Board.
  5. 5Remuneration, Removal and Penalties for Cost AuditorFinish with remuneration, removal and default consequences, which build on all earlier topics.

How to prepare Cost Auditor

Treat this as a rule chapter. Your aim is to state each rule exactly and apply it to a short fact pattern.

  1. Read Section 148 sub-section by sub-section and write one line for each in your own words: (1) cost records, (2) audit order, (3) appointment, (4) addition to Section 143 audit, (5) rights and report to Board, (6) filing with Government within thirty days, (7) further information, (8) penalties.
  2. Make a one-page table-style list in your notes of who is covered by cost records and by cost audit, using the thresholds in the Companies (Cost Records and Audit) Rules. Check the current figures in your ICMAI study material and Rules before the exam.
  3. Memorise the two provisos in Section 148(3): the company's statutory auditor under Section 139 cannot be appointed as cost auditor, and the cost auditor must comply with cost auditing standards issued by the Institute with Central Government approval.
  4. Practise case scenarios: for each, ask in order: is the company covered, who appointed the auditor, is the auditor eligible and independent, did the auditor act within rights and duties, and what is the consequence of default.
  5. Write short answers of five to six lines that begin with the rule, then apply it to the facts, then conclude. Time yourself.
  6. Before the exam, do a mixed MCQ set to test sub-section numbers, time limits and the difference between the audit under Section 148 and the audit under Section 143.

Common mistakes in Cost Auditor

  • Saying the cost auditor reports to the Central Government

    Fix: Remember the two steps: the cost auditor submits the report to the Board; the company then files it with the Central Government within thirty days of receiving a copy.

  • Allowing the statutory auditor to also do the cost audit

    Fix: Recall the first proviso to Section 148(3): a person appointed under Section 139 as auditor of the company cannot be appointed for the cost audit.

  • Treating cost audit as a replacement for the financial audit

    Fix: Cost audit under Section 148 is in addition to the audit under Section 143. State this in any answer on scope.

  • Confusing cost records applicability with cost audit applicability

    Fix: Keep separate lists: first the classes required to keep cost records, then the subset that also needs audit. Check thresholds in the Rules before quoting figures.

  • Quoting the wrong authority for appointment or remuneration

    Fix: Write that the Board appoints the cost auditor and the remuneration is determined by the members in the prescribed manner.

  • Giving penalty answers without naming who is liable

    Fix: Separate the two: the company and officers in default under Section 147(1), and the defaulting cost auditor under Section 147(2) to (4).

Last-day revision: Cost Auditor

  • Section 148 lets the Central Government direct that cost records be kept by specified classes of companies.
  • Under Section 148(2) the Government may direct a cost audit for covered companies above prescribed net worth or turnover.
  • The cost auditor is a cost accountant appointed by the Board, with remuneration determined by the members in the prescribed manner.
  • A person appointed as company auditor under Section 139 cannot be appointed for the cost audit.
  • The cost auditor must comply with the cost auditing standards issued by the Institute of Cost Accountants of India with Central Government approval.
  • The cost audit is in addition to the audit under Section 143.
  • The cost auditor reports to the Board of Directors, not directly to the Central Government.
  • The company must furnish the cost audit report to the Central Government within thirty days of receiving a copy, with full explanation of every reservation or qualification.
  • The Central Government may call for further information and the company must furnish it within the specified time.
  • Qualifications, disqualifications, rights, duties and obligations of auditors under the Chapter apply to the cost auditor so far as applicable.
  • The company must give the cost auditor all assistance and facilities for auditing cost records.
  • Default: the company and officers in default are punishable under Section 147(1); the cost auditor under Section 147(2) to (4).

Cost Auditor practice questions

Cost Auditor in other exams

The same ground in other exams, if you are preparing for more than one or want another angle on it.

Cost Auditor: frequently asked questions

Who can be appointed as a cost auditor under Section 148?

The audit is conducted by a cost accountant appointed by the Board. A person appointed as the company's statutory auditor under Section 139 cannot be appointed for the cost audit. Check the Rules for further eligibility conditions.

Is cost audit under Section 148 the same as the audit under Section 143?

No. Section 148(4) says the cost audit is in addition to the audit under Section 143. They have different purposes, auditors and reports.

To whom does the cost auditor submit the report?

The report on the audit of cost records is submitted to the Board of Directors. The company then furnishes a copy to the Central Government within thirty days of receiving it, with full information and explanation on every reservation or qualification.

What standards must a cost auditor follow?

The cost auditor must comply with the cost auditing standards, meaning those issued by the Institute of Cost Accountants of India with the approval of the Central Government.

How should I prepare this chapter for Section A MCQs?

Learn Section 148 sub-section by sub-section and practise short case scenarios. Focus on who appoints, who is barred, who reports to whom, time limits and penalty provisions.