Skip to content

CS Executive · Jurisprudence, Interpretation and General Laws

Law relating to Evidence under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023

Law relating to Evidence decides what a court may accept to prove a fact. It is now governed by the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023. To score, learn the definitions first, then relevancy, proof of documents and witnesses. In each answer state the provision, apply it to the facts, and give a clear conclusion.

What this chapter covers

This chapter covers the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA). It tells you which facts a court can hear about, how those facts are proved, who must prove them, and which witnesses and documents the court can accept. It replaces the old Evidence Act, so write BSA and its section numbers in your answers.

The chapter has a clear logic. Section 3 says evidence may be given of facts in issue and relevant facts, and of no others. Everything else builds on that. Facts are proved by oral evidence or by documents. Section 54 says all facts, except the contents of documents, may be proved by oral evidence. So contents of documents need documentary proof, and secondary evidence is allowed only in the cases listed in section 60. Electronic records are treated as documents, and their contents are proved as section 62 directs, in accordance with section 63.

In Paper 1 this chapter sits beside the jurisprudence and general law lessons. Jurisprudence gives you ideas such as fact, right and liability. Evidence shows how a court tests those ideas in a dispute. The chapter is also useful for later papers, because company, tax and securities disputes all depend on proof by documents, including electronic records. Your answers are written, so the ability to state a rule and apply it to a short fact pattern matters most.

Evidence is a rule-based chapter with precise definitions and lists, so a student who knows the wording can write short, accurate answers. Examiners like problems where you must decide whether a statement is relevant, whether secondary evidence is allowed, or whether a document is proved. These reward method, not memory alone. The chapter is also compact. A focused revision of definitions in section 2, the secondary evidence provisions and the burden of proof rules can lift your Paper 1 answers, and it helps your Paper 1 aggregate towards the 40% needed in each paper.

Law relating to Evidence: topics in the order to study them

  1. 1Introduction and Key Definitions under BSA 2023Terms such as fact, facts in issue, relevant, proved, disproved, not proved, may presume and shall presume in section 2 are used in every later topic.
  2. 2Relevancy of Facts and Evidence of Facts in IssueSection 3 sets the basic rule that only facts in issue and relevant facts may be proved, so you need it before studying specific kinds of evidence.
  3. 3Admissions, Confessions and Dying DeclarationsThese are the main exceptions and special categories of statements, and they build on the idea of relevancy and the definition of admission in section 15.
  4. 4Oral and Documentary Evidence and Secondary EvidenceOnce you know what is relevant, you learn how it is proved: orally under section 54, or by documents, with secondary evidence allowed in the cases in section 60.
  5. 5Electronic Records as EvidenceThe definition of document now includes electronic and digital records, so this topic makes sense only after you understand documentary proof.
  6. 6Burden of Proof, Presumptions and EstoppelIt uses the definitions of shall presume and may presume, and it tells you who must prove what, including the burden in section 107.
  7. 7Competency, Privilege and State Affairs EvidenceAfter the rules of proof, you study who may testify and what may be withheld, including section 129 on unpublished official records.
  8. 8Examination of Witnesses and Improper EvidenceThis is the courtroom procedure stage, and it ties together everything before it, including section 140 on the order of examination.

How to prepare Law relating to Evidence

Evidence rewards a layered method. Learn the vocabulary, then the rules, then practise applying them to facts in writing.

  1. Read section 2 until you can state each definition in your own words, especially proved, disproved, not proved, may presume and shall presume.
  2. For each topic, write the rule, its conditions and one illustration on a single revision card. Keep the exact BSA wording of key phrases.
  3. Make lists for the provisions that students confuse, such as the cases in section 60 and the kinds of secondary evidence in section 58, and learn what each clause allows.
  4. Practise short fact problems. Write the provision, apply it to the facts in two or three lines, then give a clear conclusion.
  5. Link topics when you revise. For example, connect section 54 (oral evidence), section 60 (secondary evidence), section 62 (electronic records) and section 107 (burden of proving facts needed to make evidence admissible).
  6. In the last week, rewrite from memory the definitions and the lists. Check against the Act and fix gaps.

Common mistakes in Law relating to Evidence

  • Using the old Evidence Act or its section numbers.

    Fix: Study from the BSA, 2023 only. Cite BSA sections in answers, and mention the old Act only if a question asks for a contrast.

  • Mixing up facts in issue and relevant facts.

    Fix: Remember that facts in issue are the facts a right or liability necessarily follows from. Relevant facts are connected to them in the ways the Act describes. Test each with a murder-trial example.

  • Treating oral evidence as acceptable for the contents of a document.

    Fix: Quote section 54 with its exception. Then ask whether the original is available or whether a case under section 60 allows secondary evidence.

  • Saying any secondary evidence is admissible in every case in section 60.

    Fix: Learn the Explanation. In some cases any secondary evidence is admissible, in some only the written admission, and in some only a certified copy.

  • Confusing shall presume with may presume.

    Fix: Write the two definitions side by side. Under shall presume the court must treat the fact as proved until disproved. Under may presume it has a choice.

  • Writing a conclusion-free answer to a fact problem.

    Fix: Use three steps every time: the provision, the application to the given facts, and a one-line conclusion stating whether the evidence is allowed.

Last-day revision: Law relating to Evidence

  • Section 3: evidence may be given of facts in issue and relevant facts, and of no others.
  • Fact includes anything perceived by the senses and any mental condition a person is conscious of.
  • Proved: the court believes the fact exists or thinks it so probable that a prudent man would act on it.
  • Disproved is the mirror image. Not proved means neither proved nor disproved.
  • Shall presume: the court must regard the fact as proved unless and until it is disproved. May presume: the court may regard it as proved or call for proof.
  • Section 54: all facts, except the contents of documents, may be proved by oral evidence.
  • Document includes electronic and digital records, such as emails, messages and server logs.
  • Section 62: the contents of electronic records are proved in accordance with section 63.
  • Section 60 lists when secondary evidence is allowed, such as when the original is lost or destroyed without the party's default.
  • Under section 60, for a public document or a certified copy case, only a certified copy is admissible, not other secondary evidence.
  • Section 107: whoever wants to give evidence of a fact must prove any fact needed to make that evidence admissible.
  • Section 129: no evidence from unpublished official records on affairs of State without the permission of the head of the department concerned.

Law relating to Evidence practice questions

Law relating to Evidence in other exams

The same ground in other exams, if you are preparing for more than one or want another angle on it.

Law relating to Evidence: frequently asked questions

Which Act should I study for Law relating to Evidence in CS Executive?

Study the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023. It is the current law of evidence, and you should cite its sections in your answers. Use the old Evidence Act only if a question asks you to contrast it.

Is Evidence a theory chapter or a problem-solving chapter?

It is both. Paper 1 is a written paper, so you must know definitions and lists accurately. You must also be able to apply a provision to a short set of facts and end with a clear conclusion.

How should I learn the cases of secondary evidence?

Read section 58 for what counts as secondary evidence and section 60 for when it may be given. Make a short table-like list in your notes with each case and what is admissible, and revise the Explanation to section 60 carefully.

Are electronic records covered in this chapter?

Yes. The definition of document in section 2 includes electronic and digital records. Section 62 says their contents may be proved in accordance with section 63, so study these together with documentary evidence.

Where does Evidence fit in the CS Executive syllabus?

It is part of Paper 1, Jurisprudence, Interpretation and General Laws, in Group 1. Paper 1 is a descriptive paper of 100 marks, and you need at least 40% in it to pass the group.