ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Leader · Governance scope and approaches
A council-owned leisure trust has a board made up mostly of council officials who also approve the trust's budget as the funder. A review finds the trust's managers rarely challenge the board, and service users have no formal voice. Which reform would most directly improve governance while reflecting the multiple stakeholders of a public body?
Appointing independent non-executive members, adding service-user representation and separating funder oversight from board duties is the best reform. It tackles lack of challenge, conflicts of interest and stakeholder exclusion, whereas the alternatives reduce oversight, accountability or abandon the public service purpose.
- AAppoint independent non-executive members and include service-user representation, with clear separation between funder oversight and board dutiesCorrect
- BReplace the board with a single executive who reports only to the council
- CRemove all performance reporting to reduce cost
- DRequire the trust to maximise commercial profit above its service aims
Explanation
The problems are lack of independence, conflicts between funder and board roles, and absent user voice. Independent members, user representation and role separation address all three. A single executive removes oversight, dropping reporting reduces accountability, and profit maximisation ignores the public service mission.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Governance scope and approaches shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Governance scope and approaches questions
- Halden Plc has dispersed shareholders and an executive team that controls the information flow to investors. The board is proposing the foll…
- After a collapse, an inquiry into Corvane Bank found that the board had approved a high-risk trading strategy because executive bonuses were…
- Taravale plc has a fully compliant board on paper: a majority of independent non-executives, an audit committee and a code of ethics. Yet af…
- Marlow Group's board is debating whether governance should be judged only by regulatory compliance. The chair proposes that the board should…
- Kessler Holdings plc is listed under a comply-or-explain code. Over several years, the chair has not adopted the recommended separation of c…
- Brandt plc wants to reduce agency costs between its shareholders and senior executives. The board proposes that executive bonuses depend sol…