ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Leader · Management and internal control systems
Aldous Retail has strict rules requiring three-way matching of orders, receipts and invoices, and managers must approve all purchases above a limit. The internal auditor finds that managers, under pressure to meet profit targets, regularly split orders to avoid approval limits. Which conclusion best reflects the weakness in the control system?
The weakness is that action controls are undermined by a poor control environment and conflicting pressure from profit targets. Managers split orders to evade approval limits, so rules alone fail unless culture, incentives and tone at the top support compliance.
- AAction controls are adequate, so only the targets need changing
- BDetailed action controls alone are undermined by a weak control environment and conflicting results pressuresCorrect
- CThe company should abandon results controls entirely and rely on rules
- DThe weakness is solely a lack of segregation of duties
Explanation
Rule-based action controls exist but are circumvented because targets create pressure and the tone in the control environment tolerates it. Strengthening the control environment and balancing incentives is needed, not just more rules. Abandoning results controls is unrealistic, and segregation of duties is not the problem described.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Management and internal control systems shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Management and internal control systems questions
- Tamsin, an internal auditor at Okoro Energy, discovers that the finance director appears to have manipulated reserve estimates. She fears re…
- Kestrel Logistics' board wants a framework for designing and assessing internal control across the whole organisation, covering a control en…
- Mirabel Foods Inc.'s internal auditors have just completed a review that found weak authorisation controls over supplier master data. The ch…
- Dalmore Retail's board is reviewing its approach to controls. Management proposes a compliance-based approach to preventing fraud, with deta…
- Halvorsen Logistics has a finance clerk who also approves supplier invoices, raises payments and reconciles the bank account. The audit comm…
- Marlow Group is a listed company whose audit committee has only two members, both of whom are executive directors. A new investor asks what …