ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Leader · Management and internal control systems
Dalmore Retail's board is reviewing its approach to controls. Management proposes a compliance-based approach to preventing fraud, with detailed rules and strict monitoring. A non-executive argues that this alone will fail, as staff will look for loopholes and compliance may crowd out judgement. Which proposal best addresses the non-executive's concern?
Complementing the rules with an integrity-based approach best addresses the concern. Shared values, ethical tone from the top and training encourage staff to act properly even where no rule applies. More rules would simply invite further loophole hunting, and external auditors do not own the control environment.
- AComplement rules with an integrity-based approach built on shared values, ethical leadership and trainingCorrect
- BAdd further detailed rules for each identified loophole
- CMove all monitoring to the external auditors
- DRemove the whistleblowing policy to reduce reporting noise
Explanation
Compliance approaches rely on rules and enforcement, and can encourage minimal compliance. An integrity-based approach embeds values and judgement, so it addresses the concern. More rules repeats the weakness, and removing whistleblowing weakens control.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Management and internal control systems shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Management and internal control systems questions
- Brightwater Ltd's external auditor has audited the company for 14 years and, in addition, provides tax planning and system design consulting…
- Zenith Logistics Ltd is considering outsourcing its internal audit function to a firm of accountants. Management wants specialist IT audit s…
- Harlow Freight's warehouse manager raises purchase orders, approves supplier invoices and releases payments to suppliers without any second …
- Brindle Retail has an in-house internal audit team reporting to the finance director, who also approves its budget and annual plan. The team…
- Norvale Foods plc has a small finance team and no internal audit function. The audit committee asks whether it should set up an in-house int…
- Brightwell Ltd's external auditor has provided audit services for 12 years and, in the same period, also designed the company's new internal…