Skip to content

CFA Level I · CFA Level I Exam · Equity Analyst Research Reports

An analyst writes a report with a Buy rating but the valuation section shows that the target price implies a 3% return below the firm's Buy threshold. Which statement about this report is most accurate?

The rating is inconsistent with the supporting valuation, which weakens the report's reliability. A recommendation must follow logically from the analysis and the firm's defined rating criteria. A Buy label on a target return below the Buy threshold leaves the conclusion unsupported by the report's own numbers.

  1. AThe report is acceptable because ratings may reflect the analyst's opinion regardless of valuation
  2. BThe rating is inconsistent with the supporting valuation, which weakens the report's reliabilityCorrect
  3. CThe report is strengthened because a conservative target price reduces risk

Explanation

A recommendation should follow logically from the valuation and the firm's rating definitions. A Buy rating with a target return below the Buy threshold is internally inconsistent, so the reader cannot rely on the conclusion. Opinion does not override the stated rating framework.

Did you get it right without looking?

One question tells you little. A timed set on Equity Analyst Research Reports shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.

Practise Equity Analyst Research ReportsFree diagnostic mock

More Equity Analyst Research Reports questions