ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Leader · Managing strategic change
At Calder Textiles, a force field analysis of a proposed automation project shows strong driving forces from falling margins. The restraining forces are strong employee resistance and union opposition. The CEO proposes simply increasing pressure on staff through tougher targets and a firm deadline. According to Lewin's force field theory, what is the most likely consequence?
Increasing pressure alone is likely to raise tension and provoke stronger resistance, so restraining forces may grow and the change may not hold. Lewin suggested that reducing restraining forces, through involvement and support, is usually more effective than simply pushing harder on driving forces.
- ATension and resistance may rise, so restraining forces may grow and the equilibrium may not shift durablyCorrect
- BRestraining forces will disappear because pressure unfreezes the organisation
- CThe change will be permanent because the driving forces now exceed all restraints
- DResistance becomes irrelevant because the margins data justifies the change
Explanation
Lewin argued that adding driving pressure often raises tension and provokes stronger restraining forces, leaving the organisation in a more stressed equilibrium. Reducing restraining forces, for example through consultation and training, is usually more effective. Options claiming resistance vanishes or becomes irrelevant ignore this dynamic.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Managing strategic change shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Managing strategic change questions
- Orlin Retail has completed a store redesign programme. Sales initially rose, but within a year managers and staff had returned to old routin…
- Ardent Foods wants to change from a family-run business to a professionally managed group. Context analysis shows low diversity of views, am…
- Corvane Energy is restructuring. Its trade union is powerful, and its members will lose overtime pay under the plan. Management wants to avo…
- Kestrel Foods faces collapsing sales after a product safety scandal. The new board decides to replace the senior team, close half its plants…
- Harrow Pharma must implement a new regulatory compliance process within four weeks or face penalties. There is no time for consultation, and…
- Tessmark Retail's board has found that it must close half its stores within four months because lenders will otherwise withdraw funding. Usi…