ACCA Strategic Professional · Advanced Performance Management · Performance improvement models and techniques
Dunmore Retail benchmarks inventory turnover across its 40 stores and finds that Store 12 achieves 11 times per year against a company average of 7. Management proposes to copy Store 12's stock policies chain-wide immediately. Which concern is most valid?
The most valid concern is that Store 12's high turnover may result from local factors like product mix or location rather than better practices, so the policies may not transfer. Benchmarking needs root-cause analysis of why the gap exists before practices are copied across the chain.
- AStore 12's figure may reflect local factors such as product mix or location, so the practices may not transferCorrect
- BInternal benchmarking cannot be used for inventory measures
- CTurnover figures from one store are always unreliable
- DBest practice is only relevant when it comes from external organisations
Explanation
A key limitation of benchmarking is that differences in context, such as product mix, store size or customer base, can explain the gap, so analysis of the causes is needed before copying practices. Internal benchmarking is valid for inventory, and best practice can be internal.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Performance improvement models and techniques shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Performance improvement models and techniques questions
- Verdant Insurance is re-engineering its claims handling. Currently a claim is passed sequentially between a registration clerk, an assessor,…
- Marlow Telecom benchmarked its customer call centre against a leading competitor and found its cost per call was 20% higher. Management imme…
- Pinnacle Bank's retail division has run a kaizen programme for three years, with staff suggesting small improvements to loan processing. Man…
- Harbour Logistics Ltd's order-to-delivery process passes through nine departments, each of which checks and approves the order before handin…
- Kestrel Ltd makes three products using a single machine that is the only bottleneck. Product X sells for $50 with material cost $20 and uses…
- Verano Ltd has adopted TQM. A divisional manager proposes the following: (1) appoint a quality inspector to check all output at the end of t…