ACCA Strategic Professional · Advanced Performance Management · Non-financial performance measurement
Halden Retail has set a store-level target of reducing staff turnover from 30% to 20%. The HR director notes that stores can hit the target by not hiring seasonal workers and by moving poor performers to other stores before year-end. Employees in a pilot store also report that they cannot influence turnover because pay bands are set centrally. Which combination of design weaknesses is present?
The measure suffers from poor controllability and manipulation risk. Store managers cannot influence pay bands set centrally, a key driver of leavers, and they can hit the target by avoiding seasonal hires or moving poor performers. A well-designed measure should be controllable and resistant to gaming.
- ALack of controllability and susceptibility to manipulationCorrect
- BLack of quantification and excessive timeliness
- CExcessive number of measures and lack of benchmarking
- DShort-termism and lack of ownership by the board
Explanation
Managers can manipulate the figure by redefining who counts as turnover, and store managers cannot control pay bands, a main driver of leavers. So the measure suffers from manipulation risk and poor controllability. It is clearly quantified and no evidence of too many measures or board disengagement is given.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Non-financial performance measurement shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Non-financial performance measurement questions
- Orlando Pharma uses a quality measure: defects found per 1,000 units. Last year production was 2,400,000 units with 7,200 defects found at f…
- Karst Logistics is implementing a balanced scorecard. The finance director suggests that, for the internal process perspective, the company …
- Marlowe Components plc is redesigning its performance measurement system using the Performance Prism. The finance director proposes starting…
- A manufacturer is rolling out a new set of non-financial KPIs across its plants. Which implementation step is most likely to improve accepta…
- Harbour Logistics, a freight company, assesses its divisional managers solely on quarterly operating profit. One manager has deferred vehicl…
- Zentra Retail's board uses the Performance Pyramid (SMART system) developed by Lynch and Cross. The managing director wants to identify the …