ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Leader · Professionalism, ethical codes and the public interest
Lindqvist Energy's board asks its CFO, Ana, to publish a sustainability report highlighting only favourable emissions data. Legal advice says omitting the adverse data is not unlawful. Ana believes investors would be misled. Which statement best reflects the professional stance Ana should take?
Ana should press for balanced disclosure because professional duty, grounded in integrity and the public interest, goes beyond mere legal compliance. Omitting adverse data that would mislead investors is inconsistent with professional ethics even if it is lawful.
- ALegal compliance alone satisfies professional duty, so she should publish the report
- BHer duty to act in the public interest and with integrity goes beyond minimum legal compliance, so she should press for balanced disclosureCorrect
- CShe should publish the report but disclaim personal responsibility in a footnote
- DHer duty is solely to the board, so she should follow its instruction
Explanation
Professional ethics, based on integrity and objectivity, can require more than legal compliance, especially where users could be misled. Disclaiming responsibility in a footnote does not cure the misleading presentation. Loyalty to the board does not override the public interest duty.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Professionalism, ethical codes and the public interest shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Professionalism, ethical codes and the public interest questions
- Dara Engineering's CEO is asked to approve a policy in a country where bribing officials to speed permits is routine. He says: 'When in Rome…
- Daniel, a Chartered Certified Accountant, is finance director of Brightwave Ltd. At a dinner, a friend who works for a rival asks about Brig…
- Lumen plc's board is deciding on a controversial restructuring. The chair says: 'Before we vote, ask whether we would be content for every c…
- Marlow & Co, an audit firm, has audited Danvers plc for nine years. The audit engagement partner has recently been invited to join Danvers' …
- Tomas is the group financial controller of Alder Group. The CEO instructs him to defer recognising a large known liability so that a bank co…
- Marta, a finance director at Orlen Foods, is asked to advise the board on whether to close a loss-making plant that employs most workers in …