CS Professional · Drafting, Pleadings and Appearances · Types of Documents
Meridian Traders Pvt Ltd signed a supply agreement with Kaveri Agro. Clause 5 states the price is 'Rs. 2,40,000 (Rupees Two Lakh Forty Thousand only)'. In the schedule the same price is typed as Rs. 2,04,000. Applying the usual rule of interpretation for conflicting figures and words, which amount will ordinarily prevail?
Rs. 2,40,000 prevails. When a document states an amount in words and a different amount in figures, courts ordinarily prefer the words, since figures are more easily mistyped or altered. The conflict can therefore be resolved, and the contract is not void.
- ARs. 2,04,000, because the schedule is more detailed
- BRs. 2,40,000, because words generally prevail over figuresCorrect
- CThe average of the two amounts
- DNeither; the contract is void for uncertainty
Explanation
Under the usual rule of construction, where words and figures conflict, the words are preferred because they are less prone to typing error. The schedule figure is a numeral, so it yields. Treating the contract as void is wrong because the ambiguity is resolved by the rule.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Types of Documents shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Types of Documents questions
- Meera Traders sends a signed letter to Kiran Exports stating, 'We shall supply 500 units at Rs 200 per unit by 30 June.' Kiran Exports repli…
- A lease deed between Anand Estates and Zenith Retail contains a typed clause giving a 3-year term. Beside it, a handwritten and initialled i…
- Rahul writes a letter to Pooja admitting that he owes her Rs 50,000 and promising to repay it. He signs it but does not use any formal words…
- Mehta Industries leases a godown to Joshi Logistics for a fixed term of 11 months by an unregistered written lease deed. A CS is asked about…
- Meera Traders executes a written document transferring ownership of its godown in Pune to Karan Enterprises for a price paid in full, and th…
- Anil and Bhavna sign a deed in which Anil gives his flat to Bhavna out of natural love, with no payment, and Bhavna accepts it during Anil's…