ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Leader · The internal resources, capabilities and competences of an organisation
Tavish Retail benchmarks against Corvane, its closest rival. Tavish's staff cost per sale is 12% lower, but its customer satisfaction is 20 points lower and its repeat purchases are falling. The CEO concludes Tavish is more capable. Which criticism of this conclusion is most valid?
The valid criticism is that the CEO judged capability on cost efficiency alone. Falling satisfaction and repeat purchases show Tavish may be failing on what customers value, so capability must be assessed against customer value and sustained performance, not just lower staff cost per sale.
- ABenchmarking should only use financial measures
- BEfficiency has been compared in isolation; capability must be judged against what customers value and sustained performance, not cost aloneCorrect
- CCompetitor benchmarking is unreliable because data about rivals is always unavailable
- DLower costs always indicate superior core competences
Explanation
Capability is about delivering value that customers appreciate in ways hard to imitate. Lower cost with falling satisfaction and repeat sales suggests Tavish may be under-investing in service. Cost alone does not prove superior competence, and non-financial measures are essential.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on The internal resources, capabilities and competences of an organisation shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More The internal resources, capabilities and competences of an organisation questions
- Brindle Telecom has invested heavily in a network of base stations, a customer database and a billing system. A strategy review finds that a…
- Ostrander Pharma wants to assess whether its research capability is a threshold capability or a unique resource. Which test best identifies …
- Calder Foods has a patented fermentation process that is valuable, rare and costly for rivals to imitate. The company has a well-staffed R&D…
- Ostrava Components compares its machine downtime, defect rate and cost per unit across its four factories to identify which plant has the be…
- Keswick Foods buys fruit from growers, processes it into juices, and sells through supermarkets. Its board wants to find where it can gain c…
- Norvik Hotels' board argues that its prime beachfront sites, its trained staff, and its 'warm hospitality' culture all give advantage. Analy…