Skip to content

CMA Intermediate · Management Accounting

Divisional Performance Measurement for CMA Inter Management Accounting

Divisional performance measurement judges how well a division and its manager perform. You use ROI (profit ÷ capital employed), residual income (profit − capital charge), EVA (post-tax operating profit less a capital charge), transfer prices for inter-divisional sales, and non-financial measures such as the balanced scorecard. Solve by choosing the right profit and capital figures, then interpret the result.

What this chapter covers

This chapter deals with a simple question: when a company is split into divisions, how do you tell whether each division is doing well? Head office gives each division capital and decision powers. It then needs numbers to judge results, reward managers and decide where to invest more.

You start with the basics: types of responsibility centres, controllable and non-controllable items, and why the manager's performance and the division's economic performance are different things. Then come the three return-based measures: ROI, residual income and EVA. Each has a formula, and each can push managers towards good or bad decisions. After that, transfer pricing covers the price at which one division sells goods or services to another. The chapter ends with the balanced scorecard and other non-financial measures, which cover what profit figures miss.

This chapter links closely to the rest of Management Accounting. It uses cost-volume-profit thinking, relevant costing and budgeting and standard costing. Cost of capital from Financial Management helps with the capital charge. Many MCQs and short numerical questions here are quick to solve once the formulas are clear.

This chapter is formula-light but concept-heavy, which makes it a dependable scoring area. Numerical questions on ROI, RI and transfer pricing follow a fixed layout, so you can earn full step marks with practice. Theory questions ask you to compare measures and give an opinion, and short, structured answers score well. The same ideas also show up in the compulsory MCQ section, where one clear concept can win 2 marks in under a minute.

Divisional Performance Measurement: topics in the order to study them

  1. 1Divisional Performance Measurement BasicsYou need the vocabulary first: responsibility centres, controllable items, and the aims and limits of divisional measures.
  2. 2Return on Investment (ROI)It is the simplest and most common measure, and RI and EVA are best understood as fixes for its weaknesses.
  3. 3Residual Income (RI)It builds directly on ROI by adding a capital charge, so you can see why the two can give different decisions.
  4. 4Economic Value Added (EVA)It is a refined version of RI with adjusted profit and capital, so learn it after RI.
  5. 5Transfer PricingIt needs the earlier measures, because the transfer price changes each division's profit, ROI and RI.
  6. 6Balanced Scorecard and Non-Financial MeasuresIt is mostly theory and closes the chapter by showing what financial measures leave out.

How to prepare Divisional Performance Measurement

Treat this as a chapter of small formulas plus clear reasoning. Aim to solve each type of problem in a standard layout and to explain the result in a sentence or two.

  1. Read the basics once and write down the definitions of investment centre, profit centre and controllable cost in your own words.
  2. Learn the ROI, RI and EVA formulas and fix what goes into profit and capital employed: say which profit figure and which capital base the question uses before you calculate.
  3. Solve a division with all three measures side by side, then write one line on what each result tells head office.
  4. Practise decision questions: should a division accept a new project? Compare the answer under ROI and under RI, and note where they conflict.
  5. For transfer pricing, work out the minimum price for the selling division and the maximum for the buying division. Then check spare capacity and external market prices before choosing a price.
  6. Prepare a short list of the four balanced scorecard perspectives with one example measure each, then write two or three practice answers on advantages and limitations.
  7. Finish with timed MCQs on the whole chapter and review every wrong answer for the concept behind it.

Common mistakes in Divisional Performance Measurement

  • Mixing up profit and capital definitions between ROI, RI and EVA

    Fix: Underline what the question gives: operating profit, profit after tax, total assets or net assets. Use the figure the measure needs and state your assumption.

  • Forgetting the capital charge in residual income

    Fix: Always write a separate line for the capital charge before subtracting it, as in a proper statement.

  • Declaring ROI or RI as simply the better measure

    Fix: Give both sides: ROI is easy to compare across divisions but may discourage good projects; RI is absolute and encourages value-adding projects but is harder to compare between divisions of different size.

  • Setting a transfer price without checking spare capacity

    Fix: First ask whether the selling division has spare capacity and whether an external market exists, then compute minimum and maximum prices.

  • Writing generic balanced scorecard answers

    Fix: Add one concrete measure for each perspective and one line on how they connect, such as staff training leading to better processes.

  • Giving a number with no interpretation

    Fix: End each numerical answer with one sentence stating what the result means for the division or the company.

Last-day revision: Divisional Performance Measurement

  • ROI = Profit ÷ Capital employed × 100; state which profit and capital you use.
  • RI = Divisional profit − (Capital employed × Required rate of return).
  • A positive RI means the division earns more than the required return.
  • ROI can make a manager reject a project that is above the cost of capital but below current ROI.
  • RI favours accepting any project earning more than the required rate, so it aligns better with company interest.
  • EVA = Net operating profit after tax − (Capital employed × Cost of capital).
  • EVA uses adjusted figures, for example treating some spending as investment, so it is closer to economic profit.
  • Transfer price should motivate divisions toward decisions good for the whole company.
  • With spare capacity, the minimum transfer price is the selling division's marginal cost; without it, add the opportunity cost.
  • Market price is a good transfer price when an active external market exists.
  • The balanced scorecard has four perspectives: financial, customer, internal business process, and learning and growth.
  • Use controllable profit to judge the manager and a fuller profit to judge the division.

Divisional Performance Measurement practice questions

Divisional Performance Measurement in other exams

The same ground in other exams, if you are preparing for more than one or want another angle on it.

Divisional Performance Measurement: frequently asked questions

Is Divisional Performance Measurement mostly numerical or theory?

It is a mix. ROI, RI, EVA and transfer pricing give numerical questions, while the basics and balanced scorecard are mostly theory. Prepare both, since a question can ask you to calculate and then comment.

Which topic should I study first in this chapter?

Start with the basics of divisional performance measurement, then ROI, RI, EVA, transfer pricing and the balanced scorecard. This order lets each topic build on the one before it.

What is the main difference between ROI and residual income?

ROI gives a percentage return on capital employed, while residual income gives an absolute amount after charging for capital. Because RI deducts a required return, managers are more likely to accept projects that earn above that return.

How do I answer a transfer pricing question in the exam?

Find the minimum price the selling division would accept and the maximum the buying division would pay. Consider spare capacity and any external market price, then recommend a price in that range with a short reason.

Can MCQs come from this chapter?

Yes. Section A has 15 compulsory MCQs of 2 marks each across the paper, and concepts such as ROI versus RI or transfer price limits suit that format. There is no negative marking, so attempt every question.