Skip to content

CS Professional · Corporate Restructuring, Valuation and Insolvency

Regulatory Approvals of Scheme for CS Professional

Regulatory approvals of a scheme are the Tribunal sanction and related clearances needed before a restructuring takes effect. Sections 261 to 264 of the Companies Act, 2013 are omitted, so you answer from sections 230 to 232 and the IBC. Identify the scheme, state the approvals, apply them to the facts, and conclude.

What this chapter covers

This chapter covers what must happen after a scheme of arrangement, merger or demerger is proposed, before it binds anyone. The central approval is the sanction of the National Company Law Tribunal (the Tribunal), with filings with the Registrar and, for listed companies, clearances under securities law.

The topic titles refer to sections 261, 262, 263 and 264 of the Companies Act, 2013. Read the official text carefully. Sections 254, 261, 262, 263, 264, 269 and 321 are all omitted by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, with effect from 15-11-2016. They are no longer live law. The old scheme of revival and rehabilitation for sick companies has gone, and revival now runs through the IBC.

So you study these titles in two ways. First, know what the omitted sections used to cover (revival scheme, sanction, binding effect, implementation) so you can contrast them. Second, learn where the same ideas sit today: section 230 for compromise or arrangement, section 231 for enforcement and supervision, section 232 for merger and amalgamation, and the IBC for insolvency. This links the chapter to the rest of Paper 6: Corporate Restructuring, Valuation and Insolvency.

Paper 6 is a written, case-based paper, and approval questions ask you to say what must be obtained, in what order, and what the Tribunal can order. The marks go to a correct provision, analysis of the facts and a clear conclusion. Many students lose them by quoting an omitted section as current law. If you know section 232 well, and can say clearly which sections are omitted, you gain marks in restructuring questions and avoid a basic error.

Regulatory Approvals of Scheme: topics in the order to study them

  1. 1Regulatory Approvals for Schemes of ArrangementStart here for the full picture: Tribunal, Registrar and, for listed companies, securities-law clearances, built on sections 230 to 232.
  2. 2Sanction of Scheme under Section 262Section 262 is omitted. Learn how sanction works now under section 232(3), including the auditor's accounting-standards certificate.
  3. 3Scheme to be Binding (Section 263)Section 263 is omitted. Learn the binding effect today: section 232(4) transfers property and liabilities by virtue of the order.
  4. 4Implementation of Scheme (Section 264)Section 264 is omitted. Study current implementation: section 231 supervision, the 30-day filing and the yearly compliance statement.
  5. 5Scheme of Revival and Rehabilitation (Section 261)Last, because section 261 is omitted and revival now sits with the IBC. Study it as a contrast once the live provisions are clear.

How to prepare Regulatory Approvals of Scheme

Treat this chapter as a live-law-versus-omitted-law exercise. Your notes should always say which provision applies today.

  1. Make a one-page table of omitted sections (254, 261, 262, 263, 264, 269, 321), noting they were omitted by the IBC with effect from 15-11-2016.
  2. Read section 232 line by line. Learn sub-sections (1) to (8) in order: application, documents to circulate, sanction, transfer, filing, appointed date, yearly statement, penalty.
  3. Learn section 231: the Tribunal can supervise and modify a sanctioned scheme, and can order winding up if the scheme cannot be implemented and the company cannot pay its debts under it.
  4. Read the sanction matters in section 232(3), such as transfer of undertaking, dissolution without winding up, dissenting persons, employees, and listed transferor with unlisted transferee.
  5. Add the listed-company side from your study material, such as SEBI and stock exchange requirements, without attaching section numbers you are unsure of.
  6. Practise two or three case answers: provision, facts, conclusion. State the correct current section each time.
  7. Revise the timelines and penalty figures daily until they come without looking.

Common mistakes in Regulatory Approvals of Scheme

  • Quoting section 262, 263 or 264 as the current law on sanction, binding effect or implementation.

    Fix: Write that the section is omitted by the IBC with effect from 15-11-2016, then cite section 232 or 231 for the current rule.

  • Treating section 261 revival and rehabilitation as an available remedy for a sick company.

    Fix: State that it is omitted and that revival now follows the IBC process, as taught in the insolvency part of the paper.

  • Forgetting the documents to be circulated for the meeting under section 232(2).

    Fix: Learn the five items as a list: draft scheme, Registrar filing confirmation, directors' report, expert valuation report, supplementary accounts.

  • Mixing up the 30-day filing duty with the yearly compliance statement.

    Fix: Remember: the order copy is filed within 30 days; the certified statement is filed every year until the scheme is complete.

  • Ignoring the appointed date and the auditor's certificate in a scheme case.

    Fix: Check both in every fact pattern: is an appointed date stated, and is there an auditor's certificate on accounting standards?

  • Giving a theory answer without applying it to the company in the question.

    Fix: Use three parts: the provision, a few lines applying it to the named company and facts, and a one-line conclusion.

Last-day revision: Regulatory Approvals of Scheme

  • Sections 254, 261, 262, 263, 264, 269 and 321 are omitted by the IBC with effect from 15-11-2016.
  • Section 232 governs merger and amalgamation, including division, and applies sub-sections (3) to (6) of section 230 mutatis mutandis.
  • Directors of merging companies must circulate the draft scheme, confirmation of filing with the Registrar, a directors' report on effects and share exchange ratio, any valuation expert report, and a supplementary accounting statement where needed.
  • A supplementary accounting statement is needed if the last annual accounts relate to a year ending more than six months before the first meeting.
  • No scheme is sanctioned unless the auditor certifies the accounting treatment conforms to accounting standards under section 133.
  • The scheme must state an appointed date, and it is effective from that date, not a later one.
  • A certified copy of the order must be filed with the Registrar within 30 days of receipt.
  • Penalty for failing to file: ₹20,000 on the company and each officer in default, plus ₹1,000 per day after the first, capped at ₹3 lakh.
  • Until the scheme is complete, a certified yearly statement by a CA, cost accountant or company secretary in practice is filed.
  • Under section 231, the Tribunal supervises implementation and may modify the scheme or order winding up.
  • Shares the transferee company would hold in itself as a result of the scheme are cancelled or extinguished.
  • Section 343: in a winding up by the Tribunal, the Company Liquidator needs Tribunal sanction for certain compromises and arrangements.

Regulatory Approvals of Scheme practice questions

Regulatory Approvals of Scheme: frequently asked questions

Are sections 261 to 264 of the Companies Act, 2013 still in force?

No. The official text shows sections 261, 262, 263 and 264 as omitted by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, with effect from 15-11-2016. Answer from sections 230 to 232 and the IBC instead, and mention the omission where the question uses the old section.

Which section now deals with the Tribunal's sanction of a merger?

Section 232(3) lets the Tribunal sanction the scheme after checking that the procedure in sub-sections (1) and (2) was followed. It can also make provision for transfer of the undertaking, allotment of shares, dissolution without winding up, dissenting persons and employees.

What happens if a company does not file the Tribunal's order with the Registrar?

The order must be filed within 30 days of receiving the certified copy. For default, the company and every officer in default face a penalty of ₹20,000, plus ₹1,000 for each day after the first, up to a maximum of ₹3 lakh.

Can the Tribunal change a scheme after sanctioning it?

Yes. Under section 231 the Tribunal can supervise implementation and give directions or make modifications it considers necessary. If the scheme cannot be implemented satisfactorily and the company cannot pay its debts under it, the Tribunal may order winding up.