CS Professional · Drafting, Pleadings and Appearances · General Principles of Drafting
A supply agreement between Arjun Traders and Bharat Foods says 'the Buyer shall pay within 30 days' but nowhere defines from when the 30 days run. A dispute arises. Which defect in drafting is this?
This is ambiguity caused by omitting a reference point. The clause states a 30-day period but not the event from which it runs, such as invoice or delivery date, so it can be read in several ways. A well-drafted clause fixes the starting date precisely.
- AAmbiguity from an omitted reference point for computing timeCorrect
- BPatent redundancy through tautology
- CExcess use of defined terms
- DUse of the active voice
Explanation
The period of 30 days has no starting event such as date of invoice or date of delivery, so the clause admits more than one meaning. This is ambiguity caused by omission. Tautology means needless repetition, which is not the issue, and active voice is a recommended style rather than a defect.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on General Principles of Drafting shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More General Principles of Drafting questions
- Meera, a company secretary, is drafting a supply agreement for Kaveri Foods Pvt Ltd. Her draft uses 'the Buyer' in one clause, 'the Purchase…
- In a supply agreement drafted for Bharat Components Pvt Ltd, clause 4 says the buyer shall pay 'within a reasonable time' and clause 9 says …
- Sunrise Textiles Pvt Ltd's draft supply agreement says 'the Buyer shall pay within 30 days'. The drafter is unsure whether to use 'shall' or…
- Sunita is drafting a loan agreement for Bharat Finserv. The draft says 'the borrower shall repay the loan and interest on or before 31st Mar…
- Meridian Traders' draft deed of assignment says 'the Assignor shall transfer the rights to him and his heirs' but the Assignor is a partners…
- While drafting a lease deed for Arjun Traders, the draftsman writes in clause 3 that rent is Rs 40,000 per month, but the schedule at the en…