CS Professional · Drafting, Pleadings and Appearances · General Principles of Drafting
After finalising an engagement letter, the drafter notices that a long clause with several exceptions has an ambiguously placed modifier, so it could apply to one or all of the listed items. Which approach best avoids this error?
The best approach is to split the clause into short sentences or sub-clauses and place modifiers directly beside the words they govern. This removes the double meaning. Making it longer or relying on courts does not cure ambiguity.
- AMake the sentence longer to cover all possibilities
- BBreak it into short sentences or sub-clauses and place modifiers next to the words they governCorrect
- CInsert more commas and leave the structure unchanged
- DLeave it, since courts will always favour the drafter
Explanation
Ambiguity from misplaced modifiers is cured by short, well-structured sentences or sub-clauses with modifiers placed beside what they modify. Lengthening or relying on court favour increases risk; ambiguity is typically read against the drafter's side.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on General Principles of Drafting shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More General Principles of Drafting questions
- Meridian Traders' draft deed of assignment says 'the Assignor shall transfer the rights to him and his heirs' but the Assignor is a partners…
- While drafting a lease deed for Arjun Traders, the draftsman first reads the instructions, collects the title documents, and notes the parti…
- A draft sale agreement for machinery states in clause 5 that the price is payable within 30 days of delivery, while clause 9 states that pay…
- Rohan is preparing a lease deed. He uses the term 'Lessee' in the opening, 'Tenant' in clause 3 and 'Occupier' in clause 7, all for the same…
- Deepak drafts a supply agreement for Bharat Agro Ltd. It is well written but he does not verify the legal capacity of the counterparty, a ne…
- Meera, a company secretary, is drafting a loan agreement for Kaveri Textiles Ltd. She writes one long clause of 250 words with several condi…