CS Professional · Intellectual Property Rights - Law and Practice · Protection of Trade Secrets
Arjun Foods Ltd keeps its customer price list on a shared drive open to all staff, without any confidentiality marking, NDA or access control, and has also shared it casually with outside distributors. When it later sues an ex-employee for misuse, which weakness is most likely to defeat its claim?
The claim is most likely to fail because Arjun took no reasonable steps to keep the list secret. Protection needs information with the quality of confidence, and open access without markings, NDAs or controls suggests it was not treated as confidential.
- AThe list was not registered with the Registrar of Trademarks
- BThe list was not first filed as a patent application
- CThe information lacks the necessary quality of confidence because Arjun took no reasonable steps to keep it secretCorrect
- DThe ex-employee did not pay any royalty for it
Explanation
Courts require that the information be confidential, not public knowledge, and that reasonable steps be taken to keep it secret. Open access and casual disclosure to outsiders undermine this. Registration is irrelevant, since trade secrets are not registered.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Protection of Trade Secrets shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Protection of Trade Secrets questions
- Anita Foods Ltd signs an NDA with a consultant covering its recipe formulations. The NDA states that the confidentiality obligation lasts fo…
- Anand Foods Pvt Ltd in Pune has a secret blend of 14 spices used in its ready-mix curry. Only three senior employees know the full proportio…
- Bharat Software Pvt Ltd alleges that ex-employee Sameer copied source code before leaving. Sameer argues the code elements are only his gene…
- Veda Pharma Ltd., Hyderabad, has developed a confidential manufacturing process and keeps it locked away with restricted access. A rival obt…
- Meera Foods holds a customer list that it compiled over years at considerable cost and kept in a password-protected system. A departing mana…
- Lotus Beverages Pvt Ltd discloses its confidential blending method to a bottling partner under a non-disclosure agreement. The partner later…