Skip to content

ACCA Applied Knowledge · Business and Technology · Corporate codes of ethics

Dana, an accountant, is told by a colleague that a particular transaction is not specifically banned by the company's ethics manual, so it must be acceptable. Dana is uneasy because the transaction appears to mislead investors. Which weakness of a rules-based approach does this illustrate?

This illustrates the loophole weakness of rules-based approaches: people may assume that anything not explicitly prohibited is acceptable, even when it breaches the spirit of ethical behaviour, such as misleading investors. Rules cannot anticipate every situation.

  1. ARules are too broad to be understood by employees
  2. BRules are only enforceable if staff have professional qualifications
  3. CPeople may treat anything not explicitly prohibited as permitted, even if it breaches the spirit of ethicsCorrect

Explanation

A key weakness of rules is that they can encourage a loophole mentality: if no rule forbids an action, it is assumed acceptable even if it is unethical. Rules are typically specific, not broad, and enforceability does not depend on qualification.

Did you get it right without looking?

One question tells you little. A timed set on Corporate codes of ethics shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.

Practise Corporate codes of ethicsFree diagnostic mock

More Corporate codes of ethics questions