ACCA Strategic Professional · Advanced Performance Management · Performance hierarchy
Kestrel Retail's mission states that it exists 'to provide ethically sourced clothing at fair prices'. The directors of a business unit are rewarded solely on quarterly operating profit, and the unit has recently switched to cheaper suppliers with weak labour standards to meet profit targets. What is the most appropriate conclusion about the performance hierarchy?
The unit's objectives and measures are misaligned with the mission, so goal congruence is lacking. Rewarding only quarterly profit encourages cheaper, less ethical sourcing that contradicts the stated purpose. The fix is to cascade the mission into objectives, measures and rewards, not to abandon the mission.
- AThe unit's objectives and measures are not aligned with the mission, so goal congruence is lackingCorrect
- BThe mission is flawed because it conflicts with profit
- CThe reward system is appropriate because profit is the only objective that matters to shareholders
- DThe vision should be replaced with a short-term profit target
Explanation
The hierarchy requires objectives, measures and rewards to cascade from the mission. Here a profit-only measure drives behaviour that contradicts the mission's ethical sourcing purpose. The problem is misalignment and weak goal congruence, not a defect in the mission itself.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Performance hierarchy shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Performance hierarchy questions
- Delmar Logistics is deciding whether its control system should rely mainly on tight, rule-based output controls or on shared culture and tru…
- Borealis Telecom's executives receive a dashboard of 45 KPIs refreshed hourly. Senior managers say they cannot tell which indicators matter …
- Calder Hospitality plc has shareholders who want rising profits, local councils who want the company to support community employment, and le…
- Brightwater Telecom has set a CSF of 'retaining profitable customers'. The management team is selecting KPIs to monitor this CSF. Which prop…
- Kestrel Logistics states: 'To be the most trusted carrier in East Africa.' The statement describes an aspirational future position the board…
- Orlan Retail has four CSFs. The board proposes 35 KPIs, many of them reported weekly to all store managers. A consultant argues this will we…