CS Professional · Compliance Management, Audit and Due Diligence · Values, Ethics and Professional Conduct
Neha Bansal, a young Company Secretary, argues that ethical standards are unnecessary because the Company Secretaries Act already punishes wrongdoing. Which response best explains the importance of ethics beyond legal compliance?
Ethics guide judgment where rules are silent or can be circumvented, and they reinforce the disciplinary framework rather than replace it. The Act sets minimum standards and consequences, while ethical values shape everyday professional decisions and public trust.
- AEthics are needed only because law covers no professional conduct
- BEthics replace the need for any disciplinary mechanism
- CEthics guide judgment where rules are silent or can be bypassed, and reinforce the disciplinary framework rather than replace itCorrect
- DEthics matter only for members who have been convicted of an offence
Explanation
Law prescribes minimum standards and consequences; ethics guide conduct in grey areas and build trust. Option A overstates, since the Act does define misconduct through its Schedules. Option B is wrong because ethics complement, not replace, discipline.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Values, Ethics and Professional Conduct shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Values, Ethics and Professional Conduct questions
- A member asks who decides whether his application for a certificate of practice is granted or refused. Under the Company Secretaries Act, 19…
- The Director (Discipline) forms the opinion that CS Neha Kulkarni committed misconduct falling under both the First Schedule and the Second …
- A CS firm commits an offence under the Company Secretaries Act, 1980. Partner Anil proves that the offence occurred without his knowledge an…
- The Director (Discipline) of ICSI receives a complaint with the prescribed fee against a Company Secretary, Mr. Rohan Mehta. After forming a…
- The Director (Discipline) of ICSI receives a complaint with the prescribed fee against CS Meera Iyer and forms the opinion that she is guilt…
- The Council wishes to sign a memorandum with a regulatory agency of a foreign country to perform its functions. Separately, it plans investo…