CS Professional · Drafting, Pleadings and Appearances · General Principles of Drafting
While drafting a shareholders' agreement for Narmada Infra Pvt Ltd, Tanvi uses 'Promoter' in clause 2, 'Founder' in clause 7 and 'Principal Shareholder' in clause 11, all meaning the same person. What is the best correction?
The best correction is to define a single term in the definitions clause and use it consistently throughout the agreement. Using different labels for the same person suggests different meanings, creating ambiguity; consistent terminology keeps the document precise and certain.
- ADefine one term in the definitions clause and use it consistently throughoutCorrect
- BKeep all three to avoid monotony
- CReplace each with pronouns such as 'he' or 'it'
- DDelete the definitions clause entirely
Explanation
Using different words for the same thing invites an argument that different meanings were intended. The remedy is to define the term once and use it uniformly. Variety for style, pronouns that may be unclear, or removing definitions all increase ambiguity.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on General Principles of Drafting shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More General Principles of Drafting questions
- A draftsman prepares a services agreement for Nilgiri Tech Ltd. Clause 5 uses 'the Service Provider' throughout, but clause 9 refers to 'the…
- A lease deed drafted for Mehta & Sons states 'The Lessee shall maintain the premises and fixtures, fittings or equipment.' A dispute arises …
- A franchise agreement lists 'cars, trucks, buses and other vehicles' as covered assets. A dispute arises on whether a motorised forklift use…
- In a services agreement, Clause 2 says 'Services means the services listed in Schedule A'. Clause 9 refers to 'the Work' performing the same…
- A lease deed drafted for Sunrise Realty states in a clause: 'Tenant shall not sublet, assign or part with possession of the premises.' A lat…
- After finalising an engagement letter, the drafter notices that a long clause with several exceptions has an ambiguously placed modifier, so…