Skip to content

CMA Intermediate · Corporate Accounting and Auditing

Audit Report and Reporting under CARO for CMA Inter

The audit report is the auditor's written opinion on whether financial statements give a true and fair view. CARO 2020 adds specific matters on which the auditor must report for companies it covers. To solve questions, identify the opinion type first, then the reporting clause, and state a conclusion with reasons.

What this chapter covers

This chapter covers what an auditor says at the end of an audit and in what form. You learn the parts of the audit report, the four types of opinion, and how SA 705 and SA 706 change or add to the report. Then you move to the Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, 2020, which lists extra matters an auditor must report on for companies it applies to.

The chapter has two layers. The first is the general report under the auditing standards: opinion, basis for opinion, key audit matters and responsibilities. Key audit matters (SA 701) are mandatory for listed entities, and they are not communicated when the auditor disclaims an opinion. The second is the statutory layer: CARO clauses on fixed assets, inventory, loans, statutory dues, fraud, borrowings and internal financial controls. Many questions mix both, such as a case where the auditor must decide on a qualified opinion and also a CARO comment.

It connects to the rest of Paper 10 through audit evidence, company audit and the company accounts you study elsewhere. Knowing how items appear in the balance sheet helps you see what a CARO clause is testing. Treat this chapter as the point where audit work turns into a reported conclusion.

This chapter is highly scoring because questions are rule-based and scenario-based. In Section A, you get quick MCQs on opinion types and CARO applicability. In the written section, a short case asks what opinion the auditor should give or which CARO clause applies. If you learn the decision rules and a fixed answer format, you can earn step marks even when you forget small details. It is also easy to lose marks here by mixing up similar terms, so focused effort pays off.

Audit Report and Reporting under CARO: topics in the order to study them

  1. 1Audit Report: Meaning, Contents and Types of OpinionStart with the basic report structure and the four opinion types, since every later topic modifies or adds to this.
  2. 2Modifications to the Auditor's Report (SA 705)Next learn when the opinion changes from unmodified, because it depends on the nature of the matter and how pervasive it is.
  3. 3Emphasis of Matter and Other Matter Paragraphs (SA 706)Study this right after SA 705 so you can tell apart paragraphs that draw attention from those that change the opinion.
  4. 4Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, CARO 2020: ApplicabilityMove to the statutory layer by learning which companies are covered and which are exempt before reading any clause.
  5. 5CARO 2020: Clauses on Assets, Inventory, Loans and InvestmentsThese clauses follow the balance sheet order and are easier to learn as a group of asset-side checks.
  6. 6CARO 2020: Statutory Dues, Fraud, Borrowings and Other ClausesLearn the remaining clauses after the asset-side ones, since they deal with liabilities, conduct and governance matters.
  7. 7Reporting on Internal Financial Controls and Key Differences from CARO 2016Finish with internal financial controls reporting and a comparison with the earlier Order, which works best once you know the 2020 clauses.

How to prepare Audit Report and Reporting under CARO

Treat this chapter as a mix of decision rules and a checklist. Build the rules first, then memorise the clauses in groups.

  1. Read the structure of the audit report once and write the headings in order from memory until you can do it without looking.
  2. Make a small decision chart for SA 705: matter is material or not, and pervasive or not, plus whether evidence is available. Map each outcome to qualified, adverse or disclaimer.
  3. List what belongs to an Emphasis of Matter and what to an Other Matter paragraph, and note that neither changes the opinion.
  4. Learn CARO applicability with its exemptions as a short list, and revise it separately because MCQs often test it.
  5. Group the CARO clauses by theme such as assets, loans, dues, fraud and borrowings. For each, write one line on what the auditor checks and when a comment is needed.
  6. Practise short cases: decide the opinion or clause, give a reason in one or two lines, and state the wording of the conclusion.
  7. Before the exam, attempt MCQs on opinion types and CARO applicability, and check every wrong answer against your notes.

Common mistakes in Audit Report and Reporting under CARO

  • Treating an Emphasis of Matter paragraph as a qualification.

    Fix: Remember that an Emphasis of Matter does not change the opinion, while a qualification does. Say this explicitly in your answer.

  • Choosing adverse opinion when the real problem is lack of evidence.

    Fix: First ask whether the issue is a misstatement or a limitation on scope. Misstatement leads to qualified or adverse; scope limitation leads to qualified or disclaimer.

  • Applying CARO to every company without checking exemptions.

    Fix: Begin every CARO answer by confirming that the Order applies to the company in the question.

  • Mixing up CARO clauses and the internal financial controls report.

    Fix: Keep them in separate notes. CARO covers listed matters clause by clause; internal financial controls reporting is a distinct opinion on the control system.

  • Giving a conclusion without a reason in case questions.

    Fix: Use a fixed format: facts, rule, application, conclusion. Each part earns marks.

  • Memorising clauses as a long list with no structure.

    Fix: Group them by theme and recall what the auditor checks and when an adverse comment arises.

Last-day revision: Audit Report and Reporting under CARO

  • After the title and addressee, the report begins with the Opinion section, followed by the Basis for Opinion.
  • There are four opinion types: unmodified, qualified, adverse and disclaimer.
  • Qualified: the matter is material but not pervasive.
  • Adverse: misstatements are material and pervasive.
  • Disclaimer: the auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence and the possible effects are material and pervasive.
  • Key audit matters (SA 701) are mandatory for listed entities, and are not communicated when the auditor disclaims an opinion.
  • Emphasis of Matter draws attention to a matter already disclosed; it does not modify the opinion.
  • Other Matter paragraph refers to a matter not presented or disclosed but relevant to users' understanding of the audit or the report.
  • CARO 2020 applies to companies only if they are not specifically exempt, so always check applicability first.
  • CARO clauses are reported in a separate annexure to the auditor's report.
  • Internal financial controls reporting is a separate requirement and is not a CARO clause.
  • If a CARO clause does not apply, state that it is not applicable instead of leaving it blank.

Audit Report and Reporting under CARO practice questions

Audit Report and Reporting under CARO in other exams

The same ground in other exams, if you are preparing for more than one or want another angle on it.

Audit Report and Reporting under CARO: frequently asked questions

What are the types of audit opinion for CMA Inter?

There are four: unmodified, qualified, adverse and disclaimer of opinion. The choice depends on whether the matter is material, whether it is pervasive, and whether it is a misstatement or a lack of evidence.

Is Emphasis of Matter the same as a qualified opinion?

No. An Emphasis of Matter paragraph points users to a matter already properly presented or disclosed in the financial statements. The opinion stays unmodified. A qualified opinion changes the opinion itself.

How should I answer a CARO question in the written section?

Check that CARO applies to the company, name the relevant clause, state what the auditor must examine, and then give the reporting conclusion based on the facts. Keep each step short and visible for step marks.

Which parts of this chapter are likely in the MCQ section?

Opinion types, the difference between SA 705 and SA 706, and CARO applicability are common for quick questions. Learn them as short rules, since MCQs carry 2 marks each and there is no negative marking.