ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Reporting (International) · Provisions, contingencies and events after the reporting period
Sigma Ltd's finance director asks the financial controller to omit disclosure of a material contingent liability for an environmental claim, arguing that disclosure would harm the share price. The possibility of outflow is not remote. What should the accountant do first from an ethical and IAS 37 perspective?
The accountant should refuse to omit the disclosure, explain that IAS 37 requires it, and escalate internally if pressure continues. Share price concerns are not a valid exemption, and omitting a material, non-remote contingent liability would breach the fundamental principle of integrity.
- AOmit the disclosure to follow the director's instruction
- BDisclose it only in the directors' report, not in the notes
- CRefuse to omit the disclosure, explaining that IAS 37 requires it, and escalate internally if pressuredCorrect
- DRecognise a full provision to avoid any dispute
Explanation
IAS 37 requires disclosure of material contingent liabilities unless outflow is remote; harm to share price is not a permitted exemption except in extremely rare cases of seriously prejudicing the entity's position in a dispute, where the general nature is still disclosed. Omitting it would breach integrity and professional behaviour. A provision is wrong as outflow is not probable.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Provisions, contingencies and events after the reporting period shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Provisions, contingencies and events after the reporting period questions
- Parent plc acquired 80% of Sub Ltd on 1 January 20X5. At the acquisition date Sub was defending a lawsuit. The fair value of the potential o…
- Delta Group, a listed parent, is finalising its financial statements to 31 March 20X6. It operates in a country where a new law, enacted in …
- Orion plc has claimed $800,000 from an insurer for fire damage to a warehouse. At the reporting date the insurer has neither accepted nor re…
- Orchard Co has a 30 September 20X5 year end. Before the financial statements were authorised, the finance director, who is paid a bonus link…
- The finance director of Kappa plc asks the financial controller not to disclose a possible $5 million environmental claim, which is a contin…
- Kestrel Ltd has a five-year contract to supply components at a fixed price. Because of a rise in material costs, the unavoidable costs of me…